Questions Explored in this Episode
What happened to the DeFeo family? Did Butch DeFeo kill his family? What was his defense? Why did the Lutzes leave in 28 days? What happened in the house to the Lutzes? Were the Lutzes telling the truth? What do the children say today? Is the Amityville house haunted?
Vote on the Episode
Done listening? Go vote on what you think at ghostlypodcast.com/polls. #TeamBeliever #TeamSkeptic
Listener Mail and Questions
Listener mail is the final stories from the MJ saga. The family are still facing paranormal activity with voices and toys. Have a spooky story or question of your own (or someone you know)? Send your story or question to [email protected] or leave a voicemail at 630-448-2138 and we might read or share it on the podcast.
Ghost Story – Amityville Horror
Listen to Rebecca tell a ghost story inspired by her research into the stories told about the Amityville House.
History of Amityville
Pat tells the history of the Amityville horror. He reviews the DeFeo murders and subsequent murder trial. Afterwards, Pat describes the claims made by Richard DeFeo’s defense attorney that he and the Lutzes worked together to make up the story of the haunting. He also talks about some of the claims the Lutzes made.
The Debate
Rebecca has five stories to debate. What does the priest say happened to him? What do the children claim really happened? The ratings for this one might surprise you.
Poll Results
Find out what listeners said for the Gettysburg episode – Is Gettysburg haunted? Still need to listen to our previous episode? Check it out here.
Only In Amityville: Post-mortem
Thank you for listening to Only In Amityville! The only podcast that did what we did!
Episode 16: Psycho IV: The Beginning
Episode 16! Host, Gratton Conwill and special guest, Matt Fields discuss Psycho IV: The Beginning (1990).
Episode 15: Psycho III
Episode 15! Host, Gratton Conwill and special guest, Matt Fields discuss Psycho III (1986).
Episode 14: Psycho II
Episode 14! Host, Gratton Conwill and special guest, Matt Fields discuss Psycho II (1983).
Episode 13: Psycho
Episode 13! Host, Gratton Conwill and special guest, Matt Fields discuss Psycho (1960).
Episode 12: The Amityville Terror
Episode 12! Host, Gratton Conwill and special guest, Matt Fields discuss The Amityville Terror (2016).
Who is the host of the horror show?
Hosts Tim Long and Willie Gibbs take you on a journey through horror history! Every episode covers a year in the storied history of the genre (and the world), taking one or more films released that year and dissecting the cultural impact, themes, and real-world implications of each film.
Who hosts the weekly podcast?
The weekly podcast hosted by Chris and Lena that makes discussing all things paranormal normal. Come have a listen or share an experience. We want to know. How’s it Haunting?
Who is the host of Mask of Sanity?
A weekly podcast hosted by Melanie Peterson, an Air Force veteran turned NYC actress. Join her each week as she guides listeners through different cases of the world’s most notorious killers. Mask of Sanity is partnered with the ORACL3 Network.
When the rules of society are broken, things can get a little wild?
When the rules of society are broken, things can get a little wild. Each week we discuss a murder case, followed by a true story in the realm of the wild and bizarre. This is Wild Society, a true crime comedy podcast.
